January 16, 2008
That’s why they call them crushes. If they were easy, they’d call them something else.
Posted by heatherinparadise under Humor, Insanity, Things I love, childhood, crushes, nostalgia | Tags: Celebrities, crushes, Pygmalion, Say Anything, Sixteen Candles |
Today I got to thinking about some of the “celebrity” crushes I had when I was a young girl. I’ve assembled a list of the first 18 I could think of, and tried to put them in a rough chronological order from first to last. I’m not revealing any of my current crushes, by the way (Daniel Craig in the latest James Bond movie), so don’t bother to ask.

Speed Racer, you were my first love. Clearly it was your Japanese anime-style, giant eyes that set my little heart aflutter. Plus, you just went so darned fast, and had a sidekick chimpanzee named Chim-Chim. I was so impossibly young then it didn’t occur to me that your cartoon status would keep us tragically separated forever. Sometimes I look back on those innocent days and tears form in the corners of my normal-sized, human, green eyes. Adieu, my darling. Adieu.

The Leif Garrett thing is inexplicable, and if I didn’t remember clearly the poster I had on my door of him wearing a blue satin jacket, I’d think the entire thing a false memory triggered by repressed psychological trauma. I mean, he looks like frickin’ Farrah Fawcett, for chrissakes. In my defense, I was five years old, what did I know? Could I ever have imagined that he would grow up to be this skeevy character?


Oh, Shaun, I still hold a soft spot in my heart for you, even after all these years. Your outfit is so jaunty, the tennis sweater tossed “devil-may-care” ‘round your shoulders. It wasn’t you who was Born Late, my sweet, it was me. Hey, Deenie, won’t you come out tonight? The stars are dancin’, there’s diamonds in the moonlight/Hey Deenie, you’re the one I’m dreaming of…. Guess who pretended for several years, secretly, that her name was Deenie?

Scott Baio’s recent reappearance/despicable attack on a defenseless world has only served to deepen my shame about the depth of feeling I once held for Chachi. Now immune to his charm, when I look coldly back, it’s apparent that the only thing I ever saw in him was a resemblance to my first love, Speed Racer. But Scott Baio isn’t fit to wipe Speed’s shoes, and I think I knew it even then, deep down.

When Star Wars first came out, I was still in my brief, but ill-advised “blonde” stage, plus I thought Han Solo was old (what an IDIOT!), so Luke Skywalker was my guy. I orchestrated many dreams wherein I inserted myself into the Star Wars Saga, as Princess Leia’s little sister, Princess Julie, who got to go on intergalactic dates with Luke (since, in my opinion, Julie was the most beautiful name I’d ever heard) (and also I wouldn’t find out until Return of the Jedi that Leia was actually Luke’s sister) (gross). I loved Luke for, oh, I don’t know, maybe 3 years? And then all of a sudden, I saw him for what he was: a boring, poorly-acted puss who whines about wanting to go over to Tosche Station to pick up some power converters instead of helping his uncle with chores. So then I switched my allegiance to:

And, in all honesty, I can’t say that I’ve ever really gotten over the Han Solo thing. Case in point, our Halloween costumes from just this past October:


Here is where the crushes start to get a little complicated. I know that Willie Wonka and the Chocolate Factory came out in 1971, but I don’t remember watching it until I was about 7 or 8 years old. My crush on Gene Wilder as Willie Wonka was a little disturbing even then, but it was his ability to see through the bullshit of the jerky kids and into the good character of the poor-but-honorable Charlie that made me love him. His eyes were so kind, and he was so loving and understanding of how hard it could be sometimes to be a kid, especially a kid who didn’t have the right clothes or perfect house. Even later, when I read Roald Dahl’s book, I always pictured Gene Wilder in my mind.

Ok, Richard Dreyfuss in The Goodbye Girl. More creepy crush madness that touched upon deep-seated (but then unrealized) issues of paternal abandonment and a need for attention that would resurface much later in crushes on “real” teachers, drill sergeants, college professors, and others in perceived positions of authority. None of which were ever acted upon, of course.

I think everyone in the free world had the hots for John Travolta in Grease, so I don’t think I have anything to apologize for. I saw this as a double feature with Saturday Night Fever at the Dunes Theater in Zion, IL in 1978. Would you let your kid go to see Saturday Night Fever at 8 years old?

I’m truly ashamed of this one and wish with all my might that I could take it back. IT BURNS!

Ok, the crush was Jake Ryan in Sixteen Candles, played by Michael Schoeffling. But since I’m being perfectly honest, I can admit that I had a crush on Farmer Ted, too.

It wasn’t Tom Hulce I had a crush on, it was Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, as imagined by Milos Forman. I must have watched this movie 150 times at least. I was so revved up about Mozart that I checked out every book I could find about him in the library, and was stupefied by the discrepancy between the real story and the movie, Amadeus. That sound you hear? It’s the still-echoing sound of my heart breaking back in 1985.

David Addison in Moonlighting, NOT Bruce Willis. Please remember that.

I’ve sunk so low now I might as well tell the whole truth: I had my first-ever sex dream about Johnny Castle in Dirty Dancing. My skin just crawled off and slunk away and is going to live in the house next door where surely no one has ever had a sex dream involving Patrick Swayze.

Leslie Howard as Professor Henry Higgins in Pygmalion. Another one of those movies I watched ad nauseum. More creepy crushiness; I wanted to be changed, to be different from the person I was. And he was just the man to improve me.

Lloyd Dobler from the last great movie of the 80’s, Cameron Crowe’s wondrous Say Anything. I still love him and will until I’m in my grave. Mind you, I never confused Lloyd with the actor who played him, and have NEVER had a thing for John Cusack.

I loved just about everything River Phoenix did. I find it pretty hard to even look at this picture of him. So beautiful, talented, and young. And dead.
This concludes the first 18 crushes of my youth that I could remember. Who was your crush?
January 16, 2008 at 11:34 pm
Damn girl! are you sure you’re not a gay man masquerading as heather? You’ve named just about all the secret crushes I had as a young gay boy trying to figure out who I was! I watched Moonlighting just to see David Addison, I googled Tom Hulce to see if he still turned me on (no, he doesn’t, not now) and I did my best to look like Shaun, or Leif when I was 16…….*sigh*
January 17, 2008 at 12:34 am
brilliant!!!
….waaa waaa waaa
Leif wore pink lipstick in the blue satin jacket poster, if I recall correctly.
January 17, 2008 at 7:26 am
I think I had that blue satin jacket poster too. I am a couple of years older so I had *gasp* Donny Osmond and Shaun’s older brother David Cassidy. I shudder to think what I was thinking. I’m the same way about Tom Cruise, he was so heavenly in Top Gun but I lost all respect for him when he decided he was an asshole toward women, so screw him. I’m not ashamed to admit I still get crushes, it’s what makes life fun. Carlos Marin from Il Divo is my latest, damn that man is fine looking, more so as he gets older. Hey, with all the shit going on in my life right now, I need a little escape to dream world now & again. Thanks for rekindling memories (nightmares)
January 17, 2008 at 7:49 am
Oh, those are great. (Who knew that Julie was such a beautiful name in your eyes? I used to hate it because I thought anything containing the vowel “u” was an ugly name…
You left out Bo Duke, though. I rarely got to watch the Dukes (only at other people’s houses) but I thought he was very cute in my tender years. I saw a commercial with him in it last night - still lookin’ good! And the blond cop from Chips was pretty dreamy as well.
I’ll admit to a certain fondness for Will Smith, and I think that Russel Crowe is quite a cutie, probaby because he reminds me of James.
January 17, 2008 at 8:59 am
hey Richard Dreyfuss looks like jerry!?!?
You forgot Prince. I suppose that wasn’t a crush.
January 17, 2008 at 9:34 am
Yeah, I thought long and hard about my exclusion of Prince, but I realized that that was not a crush. That was deep, lasting love that took me 20 years from which to recover.
And Julie, you’re right. I did forget Bo Duke.
January 17, 2008 at 10:40 am
You sure you’re not into Scientology? LOL. Some of those dudes are SCARY looking.
I still love Prince. He’s the man. And so is Johnny Depp and Adam Sandler. OH, and the ROCK. Now if I could just mush them all into ONE MAN, life would be good.
January 17, 2008 at 10:42 am
I was so sure I was going to see Bon Jovi on your list Heather - don’t know why.
But as it turns out, the only actual musician is a dead Austrian!! (Not counting the popfamily crap and I will confess I’ve never heard of Lief).
You are one sick and very funny puppy.
Hope you’re feeling better today (Thurs) - I noticed the office is locked up, so I hope that doesn’t mean you’re still down for the count.
January 17, 2008 at 11:53 am
Caroline, you’re right, I didn’t have any musicians on this list…and I had plenty of musician crushes (I don’t count Leif Garrett or Shaun Cassidy as “musicians.”). Looks like I’ll have to do another one all about my musician crushes.
Keltic, I’m not a gay teen boy, but I have the taste of a gay teen boy. That’s a plus, in my opinion.
January 17, 2008 at 12:46 pm
Oh dear, here goes:
Lee Majors as Col. Steve Austin the Six Million Dollar Man
Andy Gibb - tragic, I cried for days
Shaun Cassidy and Leif Garrett are on the list as well.
Henry Winkler as Arthur Fonzarelli - “Aaaaay”
John Cusack - anyway I can get him.
Ben Stiller - yes, odd, I know.
There. I’ve embarrassed myself enough for now.
January 17, 2008 at 3:31 pm
I had an inexplicable crush on Lionel Ritchie when I was very small.
And I’m of the generation of the NKOTB! Go Jordan!
January 17, 2008 at 7:12 pm
I have several dvd’s of the old speedracer episodes……still like to watch them…..but no crush on Speed its the Mach5 I love
January 17, 2008 at 7:35 pm
I will have to say that I crushed on many of the same ones as you did. I have to include Lee Majors and Patrick Dempsey and there was also Rex Smith. He had that Farrah Fawcett Hair thing going on too. I really liked River phoenix. Wow…there are many crushes I had…lol I might have to do my own post about them.
January 17, 2008 at 7:47 pm
I wish I could extinguish all of those torches that I’ve carried for so long, but no… I would still marry Linda Carter if she’d have me and we’d buy a house big enough for us and Lindsay Wagner, too.
January 17, 2008 at 10:28 pm
this is another one of those”you can make money for articles like this,”blogs!!
My first crush was Mighty Mouse…he was too cute and could sing opera.Had a real thing for “Little Joe” of Bonanza, til I got a little older and saw the reruns and realized that the man in black “Adam Cartwright” was way hotter!!Along came the Beatles and Ringo”the funny one” got my heart..
January 17, 2008 at 11:07 pm
I have been laughing for 30 seconds straight that my mom’s first crush was Mighty Mouse. I mean, is there any question that I am my mother’s daughter?
Thank you, Donna. I love you.
January 18, 2008 at 12:22 am
Hehe- what a way to start my day over here……..hum. Let’s see what comes to mind:
William Shattner as Captain Kirk. My crush when I lived in the States and first got to see that series.
At the same time or a little later I also really crushed on the Phantom (YES- the violet masked guy from the comic series….if I remember correctly… no time to google right now). Weird- would point to some sort of SM or what have you practises in later life but no, that didn’t happen.
Then- Michael J. Fox. Posters and all.
Until A-HA dropped onto the European pop scene and Morton Harket became my new crush. First concert of mine- and I never got over the fact that my parents for some reason didn’t agree that wearing leatherstraps almost up my entire lower arm (like he did) was indeed NOT cool OR happening.
And oh yeah- that Mozart movie….. I remember crying at the end. He was cute!!!
Han Solo- yep, we agree on that one.
Another one- up until today actually: Trent Reznor! The first NIN album came out in 1989- I was 15 and he made my hormones rage. And does until today- even though the sick part is that I don’t dig the buff Reznor of today half as much as the sick druggie that he was then. Please do not try to analyze that psychologically.
I am sure there are a lot more- those are the first that come to mind though.
January 18, 2008 at 10:00 am
I cannot believe I’m admitting to my first crush (which was around the age of 5). It was Peter Pan! I thought Wendy was such a lucky lady. How could you not love a guy that could fly and had a tiny fairy for a best friend?!
Then I moved on. The anime-eyes got me too! I had a major 8 year old crush on Mark, the fearless leader of GForce, in Battle of the Planets. The only that ruined him for me later in life was when I found out the Casey Kasem was the voice behind my boy-wonder.
I then moved on to Rick Springfield (suprised that no on ehas mentioned him). I’d race home every day after school to catch the final minutes of General Hospital. Since we didn’t have a VCR yet, I tape recorded any audio of Dr. Noah Drake and then played it back again and again.
Oh…and Jake Ryan! I’m so with you on that one. I actually have an ‘I Love Jake Ryan’ t-shirt! I only wear to bed though…never in public.
I had a small crush on Jordan Catalano, but by the time My So Called Life was on the tube, I was much to old to be crushig on him since he was still in high school! I could be into Jared Leto, but he is way too pretty for me, even when he doesn’t wear all his makeup.
Tom Cruise…yeah, guilty. I just watched Risky Business with fresh eyes the other night. I actually hung my head in shame.
The only sex dream I had with a celebrity is with Jon Bon Jovi. Maybe that is why I carry such a large torch for him. It was THAT good!!
(oh god! Am I really going to submit this comment?!)
January 18, 2008 at 10:50 am
Heather, you forgot Cary Elwes, you had us watching The Princess Bride daily for awhile there.
January 18, 2008 at 1:47 pm
I have some real names to run by you for old times sake… Swish??? Dave Otto?? And Amy pointed out the obvious life long Prince hmm well I wish that I could think of a conversation that we had in our few years together that didn’t end up there …
Did you not like Willie Ames a little? or the Fonz?? And what about Tootie or Blair?? j/k
Tony Danza….
Alex P. Keaton….
Kirk Cameron…
Belky from Perfect Strangers…
Thank You
I was supposed to be paying bills on my break instead I am thinking of all these men I had crushes on which led to how do I get theses shoes on DVD that I once loved…
I am more addicted to see what you are writing than MYSPACE!!!
January 18, 2008 at 2:01 pm
Oh Cassie, no you DIDN’T drag Dave Otto into this discussion!! hahaha, but he is a real person, he doesn’t count!
And yes, I had a crush on Kirk Cameron, too, but none of those other people, you WEIRDO!
January 18, 2008 at 3:06 pm
LOVE this blog… although I was one of those pragmatic youths who did NOT have crushes like that… never, never, never. They weren’t real people to me. Now ask me about my 8th grade Social Studies teacher… sigh…..
January 18, 2008 at 3:07 pm
Also, do I get a dollar since I can identify the quote in your title?
January 19, 2008 at 7:22 am
I had a dream when I was about 8 or so that I kissed Shaun Cassidy and his mouth was so minty that it burned. Hmmm.
Anyway, definitely right with everyone on the Han Solo and Rick Springfield tip. And I swear if Jake Ryan walked into this room right now…
January 19, 2008 at 6:50 pm
Love this entry…brings back so many memories of first crushes. I too had the Scott Baio and Shaun Cassidy and Leif Garret posters in my room. And oohh Patrick Swayze is hot!! I can’t tell you how many times I have watched that one scene from Dirty Dancing!
I do have to admit to one you didn’t have your list…John Stamos…I was a General Hospital fan when he was on there as Blackie. I even went to a personal appearance to see him once. I just thought he was so dreamy!
And yeah I still think he is hot….
January 20, 2008 at 8:26 am
Pink Lady and Lindsay Wagner.
I had an 8×10 glossy of L.W. wearing, what appeared to be nothing but, a fur coat. It was signed, “To James, with all my love.”
January 20, 2008 at 10:30 am
Oh man, I second Bo Duke! Growing up in the south, that was a must. Then there was Ricky Martin (I totally had a Menudo lunchbox in 1st grade). But the posters on my teenage walls were Sebastian Bach, Vince Neil, Jon Bon Jovi, Steven Tyler (ew.), all those (now mostly old and crusty) glam rock dudes. Then there was Christian Slater from Gleaning the Cube, Balthazar Ghetty and Leonardo DiCaprio (whom I still think is rather hot)…
January 21, 2008 at 12:27 am
Sure, drag this crap out of the attics of our past…
Maddie Hayes (Cybil Shepard) - from Moonlighting. Cybil. hot. wtf!?
Erin Gray - from Silver Spoons. Never got into Buck Rogers — too bad, those outfits were t-i-g-h-t.
Any woman from the :20 minute workout.
Wonder Woman (Linda Carter) - need I say more?
Daisy Duke
Marianne (Gillian’s Island)
Heather Locklear
Tiffany
Christy Brinkley
Christina Applegate
January 21, 2008 at 8:40 pm
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v402/trixtergrl1/davidleeroth.jpg
Nuff said. LOL- It’s great to be back.
January 22, 2008 at 12:53 pm
Oh man, what a great post and thread of comments, I’m in a time machine!
My first real crush was Michael Jackson, my walls were plastered with cheap posters held up by sticky tack. Add to that any Duran Duran member (though favouring Roger, always had a thing for drummers), Christopher Reeve as Superman, Kurt Thomas the gymnast and Baryshnikov the ballet daner. Oh, and Nadia Comaneci, “She’s Perfect” and Dorothy Hamill, I kept her haircut for many, many years.
Thanks for a fun read!
January 22, 2008 at 5:27 pm
Heather I like where your head is!!! I have to say you have got me thinking and her we go
1. Ricky Schroder ( Silver Spoons)
2. Micheal Jackson
3. Any actor in the movie The Outsiders
4. Ryan Sandburg from the Cubs
5. Bo and Luke Duke from the original Dukes of Hazard……
Love ya
January 23, 2008 at 11:00 am
Oh God, you just made me laugh! I had the Andy Gibb, Shaun Cassidy, Leif Garrett and Scott Baio posters. LOL.
January 29, 2008 at 11:10 am
It’s so nice to see that all your other friends did as I did and had to walk down there memory lane of crushes…. Obviously I was kidding about a few…. But hmm Dave Otto…. How did I miss the team photo that year?? I am mad a little about that..Do you remember when that one kid….hmmmm I cant remember his name but he was the equipment manager …forgot the balls at a game and Swish went OFF on the bus where you and I were sitting?
February 14, 2008 at 11:21 pm
PRINCESS JULIE??? Nice. You totally would have had a spot in my juvenile playdates-cum-thinly-veiled-sexual-objectification-fantasties…
Ahem. Anyway, YEAH, BABY, way for switching your allegiance to Han SuperSexy Solo! Wooooo!
We now officially have a few things in common - I too vaguely, hazely remember Shaun and Leif and even Mr. Original Willy Wonka as major players in a few youthful romantic daydreams.
But where, oh where, is the glorious and eminently fuckable ADAM ANT?? Good God, woman! I thought we were soulmates… and yet…now, I am so very unsure about that…
Christ, and let’s not even GO into Johnny Depp territory….
P.S. Reading your posts, I seriously need to get my Passport renewed.
February 14, 2008 at 11:52 pm
Lizzy, I did have a crush on Adam Ant. And Prince, and John Taylor and some more musicians. I have to write an entire other list to fit all those guys in!